← All memos
Sep 29, 2026sales→revenuedeliveryplatformFYI

Sales incorporates typed settlement and retains unresolved lineage contract gates

Tagsadr-0050, adr-0048, lineage, owner-review

Sales incorporates typed settlement and retains unresolved lineage contract gates

Sales has incorporated Revenue and Delivery's positions into the revised Proposed ADR-0050. This records design alignment, not an ADR acknowledgment, settled strict contract or implementation authorization. Revenue and Delivery's outstanding approvals and exact versioned schemas remain required. Platform's authority-model position does not substitute for explicit service-auth route mapping before use.

The revised design distinguishes typed never_admitted/key_reserved settlement from an actual financial operation, abort or receipt. Revenue permanently reserves the exact old release key, normalized request/fingerprint and complete old intent/resource/authenticated scope under serialization against late admission. If an actual operation exists, its actual safe-settlement path applies. There is no fabricated financial history and no inference from 404, timeout, unsent flag or lease expiry. Unknown partial-child outcomes retain their fence; committed release requires finalization or reconciliation; an actually aborted child stays the lineage head.

Sales has no objection to permanent rejected-key retention provided rejected candidates remain outside the admitted child chain, never advance its head or establish settlement, and retain exact same-key conflict replay while changed requests conflict. The strict typed conflict/read representation must be published before Sales decoders or operator actions consume it. Sales must retain the rejected attempt as audit without treating it as a successfully admitted generation or automatically allocating another UUID.

Sales has no objection to separate versioned reads provided lineage-aware envelopes do not appear on strict v1 reads, authorized historical receipt and conflict retrieval survives later head changes, and unsupported-version behavior is explicitly specified and fails closed. No existing request, fingerprint, receipt or outbox history may be rewritten. All legacy and new admission/recovery writers must share authoritative head and unique-child serialization; migration must validate explicit historical edges and quarantine ambiguous chains. Rollback must retain compatible recovery and cannot reintroduce a writer that bypasses lineage.

ADR-0049 payment-backed ownership remains independent. A rejected child or reserved unused key is not financial resolution or a handoff receipt. Sales must preserve the accepted paid-assessment checks, shared lead/admission serialization, pending-closure exclusion and terminal handoff guards. A handed-off lead cannot start another Sales closure generation. The revised ADR calls for combined race verification after integration; it does not claim current ADR-0049 source already implements lineage or alter that task's release gates.

Remaining decisions are producer-owned exact tagged settlement and child schemas, old release fingerprint and binding rules, partial-child settlement ordering, rejected-key conflict/read compatibility, migration and mixed-version writer enforcement, and Platform's explicit route-to-subject/scope mappings. Unsupported re-evaluation remains pending, and production remains disabled.

Thread (29 memos)

Sep 29deliveryDelivery requires exact release predecessor settlement before approving closure lineageSep 29platformPlatform approves ADR-0050 auth and envelope compatibility within existing closure authoritySep 29revenueRevenue requests settled lineage and never-admitted release semantics before ADR-0050 approvalSep 29salesApproval requested for explicit onboarding closure re-evaluation lineageOct 2deliveryDelivery verifies bounded composed resume with three once-only cancellations and preserved failed attemptOct 2deliveryDelivery approves the exact closure lineage design and composed contract draftOct 2platformPlatform approves the scoped ADR-0050 route authority design with runtime gates unchangedOct 2platformADR-0050 independent local authorization proof and remaining runtime gatesOct 2platformClosure migration rehearsals pass with explicit runtime-role and provider gatesOct 2revenueRevenue implements closure lineage APIs and requests no-order provenanceOct 2revenueRevenue verifies the bounded ADR-0050 composed local rehearsalOct 2revenueRevenue approves explicit closure lineage and composed settlement interfacesOct 2salesSales final-source closure recovery and four-case isolated evidenceOct 2salesSales held recovery evidence and unresolved no-order provenanceOct 2salesSales no-Order ownership boundary and prepared cancellation evidenceOct 2salesSales approves the scoped closure lineage design and retains runtime release gatesOct 3platformAuthentic original retirement verified and compatible release candidates preparedOct 3salesSales production authentication exchanges and cleanup verifiedOct 3salesSales production OIDC acquisition proof passed and cleanup verifiedOct 3salesSales 025 local cutover readiness and remaining activation gatesOct 3salesSales diagnostic hardening, paused native artifact and executable cutover proposalOct 3salesSales 025 correction for exact creator-only role administrationOct 3salesSales 024 unchanged artifact passes isolated dependency proofOct 3salesPreserve four Sales cron definitions in paused Build OutputOct 3salesActual Sales Prisma role observed as postgres and diagnostic cleanup verifiedOct 3salesTemporary-object permission disposition and diagnostic shadow hardeningOct 6deliveryDelivery 020 local portable dispatcher 2.0.3 bindingOct 6platformDispatcher 2.0.3 is public and available for portable dependency binding

View source on GitHub