Platform collected ADR-0052 review requires one method-denial vector correction
Assignment ADR-0052/platform/005; coordinator 01a0e095-f279-7fd0-a8ef-92ce8f9547fc, host local; participant 01a0ff07-c6a3-7000-81a3-94f9960a4513. Reviewed exact assembled commit c114a77d3319e8a36d3edd0e9043e4972b895cc7 in the coordinator-owned read-only checkout, including ADR, all four owned contract packages, strict shared schemas/validators, continuation correction, release annex and CI/dependency portability changes. Review PR is https://github.com/sguild-admin/coordination/pull/3.
Position and exact finding
Platform approves the collected authorization and continuation architecture. One contract-validation inconsistency remains before formal package acknowledgment: Delivery scheduling-workload-and-bind-settlement section 2 specifies wrong method is HTTP 405 without business access, but Platform's validator combines wrong method and wrong path into 403 FORBIDDEN, and all four /wrong-method vectors expect 403. Its vector schema consequently excludes 405. The validation documentation calls these explicit HTTP classifications, so this is an inconsistent executable contract expectation rather than an alternative internal label.
Correct the Platform validator to keep wrong route denied and return 405 for wrong method on the exact route; update exactly four wrong-method expected results; permit 405 and the synthetic method_not_allowed label in the vector schema; clarify the documentation that this label is not a new wire body code. No scope, subject, audience, claims, route, producer schema or business authority changes. Concrete complete replacement files are prepared under Platform's .tmp/adr0052-final-review-correction/contracts/service-auth/validation/, with exact base/draft hashes in its manifest. The coordinator remains sole writer/publisher of the assembled package. No full acknowledges field is attached to this still-inconsistent package, rather than issuing a conditional blanket acknowledgment.
Architecture reviewed and accepted by Platform
The four exact selectors/subjects/audiences and mounted methods/routes remain isolated; no generic inspection, cancellation/refund/closure or fifth legacy receipt authority is added. Receipt/evidence disclosure requires current verified tenant/Organization/resource access and original immutable intent/key/fingerprint linkage. Per-attempt distinct audited/no-store authority, enabled exact-org sales/owner/admin plus existing app verdict, service-owned admitted recovery and bounded residual JWT validity remain explicit. Existing defaults, closure and Coaching policy blocks retain their authority.
Delivery's nonexpiring continuation protection is installed atomically with bind and original receipt under shared Lesson/bind/key/cancellation serialization. The original protected booking supplies continuation authority; historical receipt possession alone does not. Every invalidating associated writer, indirect job, raw/admin path and obsolete binary is covered by the contract obligation and later enforceable barrier proof. External Coaching/Platform facts are not falsely promised immutable; current service/resource and financial authorization remain separate requirements.
Revenue's continuation state separates awaiting bind, protected and irreversible settled/abandoned. Unknown provider dispatch/writeback or executable original work stays protected. Terminal evidence cannot reopen old collection. Delivery fetches exact evidence outside local locks, then verifies receipt/identity and CASes the same local protection generation before retirement. The waiting writer evaluates normal predicates in that transaction. The proof does not authorize cancel/refund/release itself. No cross-domain network call is held under transaction locks; common lock order, independently resolvable terminal financial decisions, bounded reconciliation and retained uncertainty address recovery deadlocks. An indefinite safety block under genuinely unknown external outcome is intentional, not a liveness claim.
Financial fence transfer is atomic, stable original provider/preparation identity survives crash/writeback failure, and genuine incoming financial/operational facts stay recordable while contradictory progression defers. Immutable admission reservation revision, current closureRevision and current intent CAS revision remain distinct; legitimate financial facts do not strand settlement on stale admission equality. Permanent noncommit defeats delayed bind, and retained exact terminal association supports later authenticated replay without reopening execution.
Scheduling v2 explicitly changes protocol/key/retention compatibility; ordering v2.9 remains additive with preserved Sales request/success/error shapes and no mandatory new Sales-to-Revenue field. Credit v3.5/release API v1.1 define fail-safe transient conflicts without new financial lifecycle/events. Legacy execution/automated receipt replay stays quarantined. The coordinated attempt is at most four hours with explicit checkpoint/extension decision, and deprecation is at most 14 calendar days from actual accepted publication. No timer unlocks protection or restores unsafe writers. Rollback preserves authentication, permanent keys, journals, fences/tombstones and quarantine.
Validation and remaining boundaries
Reused the coordinator's exact-commit combined static evidence: Platform 188 vectors plus 8 boundary probes; Delivery 44 shape and 11 semantic cases plus digests; Revenue 52; Sales 44 plus 4 format and 9 hash checks; corpus/registry/pointer checks. Did not repeat unrelated suites. Because the method-code mismatch required a change, ran the corrected Platform validator alone from the assembled coordination working directory with its pinned dependencies: all 188 vectors (12 positive, 176 denials) plus 8 boundary probes passed. This is synthetic contract evidence, not JWT cryptographic verification or actual denied-side-effect proof.
After the four-file correction is assembled, the exact corrected commit can receive Platform's formal acknowledgment. Mechanical acceptance-label removal may follow full owner approval without dropping runtime gates. No other architecture/schema blocking finding was identified in this review; no approval or implementation commitment is authored for another domain.
Actual production OIDC exchanges, issuer/recipient implementation, all covered writer/sender barriers, cancellation/release/provider interleavings, credential nonpersistence, denied business effects, compensation and protected cutover remain later implementation/activation gates. No application edit, token issuance, database mutation, runtime pause, deployment, independent publication/indexer or root-checkout mutation occurred. Live Platform inbox/ledger discovery remains separate from the unindexed review branch; no implementation commitment is claimed completed by this memo.