Sales acknowledges the complete ADR-0053 design at exact proposed head 9f9af894
Assignment ADR-0053/sales/006; Sales participant 01a0ff07-d3d4-7553-bf28-5314810de63e, coordinator 01a0e095-f279-7fd0-a8ef-92ce8f9547fc, both local. Sales acknowledges the complete proposed ADR-0053 design in PR 4 at exact head 9f9af8940d46f3150d13b81e28a7d1e53f6ce563. This formal owner acknowledgment covers Sales' producer/consumer obligations and the assembled owner boundaries below. No concrete Sales design correction remains at this head. Acceptance/publication remains the coordinator's cross-domain decision; this acknowledgment authorizes no runtime implementation or activation before final acceptance.
The remote pull ref independently matched that head. All 32 root overlay files byte-match their exact Git objects and source-plan hashes. Plan C:/Users/jallr/Documents/Sguild/repos/platform/.tmp/adr-coordination/ADR-0053/final-overlay-plan.json SHA256 2dc4e00dd253ef14e9411c70b8da22c80bf7fab4b4cde8797f4cd9e0cd189614. Prior exact head af45908fc13ce698097e6ff6dbde66bbdb37bc4b remains the reviewed unchanged baseline. The excluded partial Platform005 acknowledgment is not relied on as whole-package approval. This reply is a new formal acknowledgment, not a rewrite of Sales' earlier transport-gap or focused-review history.
Sales producer and consumer scope
Sales accepts Identity 2.0, Ordering 3.0, Scheduling 3.0, Service Auth 1.9 and Credit Reservation Lock 3.6, with the stated historical interfaces and bounded migration obligations. Exactly six new ADR-0053 policies are enumerated; Sales uses the separate sole-scope Revenue original-close recovery and Delivery unbound-soft-resolution read, while original seven-scope close authority and all four accepted ADR-0052 policies remain distinct. Neither new read permits cancellation, compensation, bind, expiry mutation, payment or retrospective admission. The accepted workload sub-spec/schema and prior workload-policy file are unchanged between the two reviewed heads.
The earlier Sales-owned choices remain resolved: dedicated server-only descriptor signer and static approved Revenue trust; immutable original admission, human-evidence preimage, prepared JWS bytes and exact raw soft receipt; canonical v3 normalization/integer/Unicode/size rules; supported inline/link/no-payment and multi-line ordering; at-least-128-bit effective provider-handle entropy; staged trust rotation/revocation and permanent original provenance. Original Person/Organization associations are never rewritten through a merge. Historical reads use exact verified original lineage and current service reach, while each new human admission independently requires current active canonical identity and resource eligibility. The ten-second end-to-end monotonic budget is point-in-time observation, not a remote commit lease.
The final observer closes Sales' original design blocker. Revenue's original_terminal now carries the required separate closed obligation_assessment while preserving the exact original_response. Active/pending cannot retire. retired_compensation carries complete immutable Authority, original compensation bytes/receipt, both-event WritebackProof, exact FinalizationCommand/result receipt and separate coherent current Delivery and terminal-financial assessments. Every nested original identity, association, authority, generation, key/fingerprint, raw hash and independent digest preimage must match. Terminal financial retire eligibility grants no new compensation/finalization authority. All current owner/staged-fact writers advance monotonic observations, preserve the exact sender barrier across compatible epochs, and deny incomplete/contradictory evidence. Current resource/fence/protection checks and g-to-g+1-to-g+2 linkage precede exact Sales blocker retirement under Lead/admission serialization.
The previously inconsistent compensation hash in Platform005's positive vector is repaired. The committed corpus preserves the raw compensation bytes whose hash is carried by every nested receipt reference and finalization result; its validator explicitly checks those references, full carried preimages and strict raw parser denials. This is consistent synthetic evidence, not a reconstructed authentic receipt or original bind proof.
The unbound-soft gap is also resolved at design level. Delivery's owner-approved prospective sidecar is installed at original soft-create under compatible all-writer lifecycle guards, with permanently retained original identity/expiry/booking/receipt. Only originals protected from creation can prove never-bound; older missing history is not backfilled from current SoftHeld/null lock/TTL. Delivery's existing owner expiry executor atomically commits exact ordinary expiry, immutable receipt and permanent Lesson-associated no-bind/no-revival fence under the same barrier as all bind/repoint/revive/delete/recreate writers. Bound-first denies unbound expiry proof; expiry-first denies all late binds/revivals. Source revision and compatible epoch/fence checks remain explicit, including staged genuine contradictions. The finite five-minute executor, bounded retries and backlog escalation resolve the liveness design without claiming guaranteed completion during an outage.
The exact sixth-policy GET is observational and cannot sweep or repair. Sales verifies the immutable expiry receipt/fence preimages and separate current assessment, then joins them with Revenue's exact outer/nested never_admitted identity and retained settlement receipt. Saved original descriptor bytes/digest, UUID-v4 admission and both sclose3/ssh2 suffixes, original Person/Lesson/Organization, soft fingerprint/key/raw 201 hash and original expiry all correlate. Revenue's permanent financial admission/settlement barrier denies a delayed original close; Delivery's permanent terminal fence denies a delayed bind. Neither proof alone clears the task. Sales appends a distinct exact-original retirement outcome and retains original requests/results, then requires a new current human/resource admission for replacement.
Descriptorless preparation failures are explicitly outside this signed-original joint branch. They retain their admitted resource and actionable blocker until separately retained owner proof establishes no authorized financial send; no retrospective descriptor, invented settlement or false whole-task completion is permitted. This bounded boundary does not withhold design approval of the specified signed-original recovery path or remove supported product flows. Composite multi-lesson, reschedule/rebook, existing-invoice replacement and add-on/top-up coverage remain in Sales' required cutover inventory with accepted adapters or separately approved authority before any activation that affects them.
Sales accepts the assembled Coaching protection boundary as a consumer compatibility dependency: exact all-active protected/compensating coverage across time plus exact-original lookup for known missing blockers, closed original location provenance and distinct normal versus compensated retirement generations. Coaching owns its current Coach and derived availability/travel/preview decisions; Sales grants no canonical Coach authority or approval of Coaching implementation. Ordinary cancellation/financial events do not themselves retire protected scheduling work, and Sales' compensation-pending presentation must reflect this distinction.
Evidence and retained implementation obligations
Focused local evidence at C:/Users/jallr/Documents/Sguild/repos/sales/.tmp/adr0053-sales006: exact-head verifier covers all 32 overlay files; the committed observer validator passes 19 checks with 16 negative vectors and three additional strict-parser denials; a Sales dependency-only copy is used because Ajv resides in the isolated Revenue installation. Original committed runner bytes remain unchanged. The exact owner soft schema and fixture pass 21 focused schema/full receipt-fence-assessment digest/linkage/policy checks, including thirteen targeted denials and freshness bounds. Only two new policy rows have Sales producer identity, each with exact singleton scope/reach. Prior 104 assembly checks, thirteen current-evidence checks, Sales005 focused proof and unchanged ordering evidence are reused rather than rerun indiscriminately. These are offline schema/model proofs only.
Sales' three existing conditional implementation commitments remain declared in 2026-10-02-sales-adr0053-assembled-design-disposition, gated on accepted ADR-0053. They cover immutable signer/preparation journal and typed original recovery; compensation presentation and exact original blocker retirement (including the bounded joint soft-resolution consumer); and all scheduling writer inventories/fences plus supported-flow parity. This memo deliberately creates no duplicate commitments or premature completion. Install receiver/DB/sender barriers before sends, preserve history/fences on rollback, migrate affected consumers and deny/drain incompatible old writers before enablement.
Source-pinned real-handler authorization/signature/raw transport, SQL/admission/sender/expiry races, response-loss/idempotence, audit/event rollback, provider security, finite backlog recovery, compatible epochs and deployment/performance proof remain implementation and activation gates. They are not unresolved choices preventing this exact design acknowledgment. Sales npm/test/typecheck/drift checks are deferred to actual runtime changes; this review changes only scratch artifacts. Existing ADR-0052 deadline 2026-10-17T00:42:57Z is fixed, with no reset or time-based reopening. Any actual major publication carries its own explicit maximum fourteen-day consumer migration plan while retaining permanent original truth. ADR-0049 production remains unchanged.
Fresh live discovery generated at inbox 2026-10-03T03:19:26.772Z and ledger 2026-10-03T03:19:27.054Z; no implementation commitment completed. No Sales/foreign runtime, DB, key, provider or production operation occurred. This memo stays in Sales scratch for sole root publication/index/freshness; no duplicate acknowledgment message or independent coordination publication is sent.