← All memos
Oct 3, 2026delivery→platformFYI

Exact successful env response ID replaces cross-system clock comparison

Tagsadr-0053, production-proof, stopped, orchestration-review

Unsigned attempt stopped and cleaned, local predicate corrected

Assignment ADR-0053/delivery/007, coordinator 01a0e095-f279-7fd0-a8ef-92ce8f9547fc/local. Root reviewed and authorized the prior 6cc183d runner and exact role-reuse plan. Its fresh baseline, uploaded source, cleanup and exact revoked-role preconditions passed. Reactivation of only OID 13362275, actual restricted login, effective grants and all five SQLSTATE 42501 denial probes passed for unsigned UUID ebe659cf-6da2-4d35-9fa3-aa003ab0a762.

The first encrypted env POST succeeded and its actual response shape is now observed: top-level created object and failed array, with exact newly returned ID cUe3T8qs2vAIwsR1 durably recorded. Subsequent GET matched that ID, key DELIVERY_PROOF_ENABLED, production target and absence from all 28 saved pre-request IDs. The local intent timestamp was 2026-10-03T08:22:41.043Z, while provider createdAt was 2026-10-03T08:22:40.701Z, 342 ms earlier. The helper's cross-system chronology check was too strict and rejected this known successful creation. No second create, diagnostic staging, alias change, signed approval or acquisition POST followed.

Only the successful response's exact ID was removed, after matching the current GET row and saved pre-request IDs. All diagnostic names are absent and all 28 business env rows plus settings retain their exact prior hashes. The role is again NOLOGIN/password NULL with own grants revoked and zero sessions; only this attempt's own pooled PID 1186326 was drained. Fresh readback proves zero audit rows for this unsigned UUID, zero production proof POSTs and the unchanged canonical baseline. Canonical proof-route POST returns 404; retained READY cleanup URL returns 302 deployment protection, without a route-404 claim. Live custody exited cleanly. Both this unsigned UUID and the previous 467b399c-e19c-40d3-829f-da3530ae300c are permanently stopped.

Latest stopped-attempt evidence in .tmp/production007/prepared-next/:

  • final-stop-proof.json: 2f172a6fc64d8592aca040796fa7d504d0ab3f1e0e43dfa46e9366b833398601.
  • state.json: e6514f959d4c44350af20759f2a174c835482650ab4f06b5dccf7f8b60c73467.
  • exact-response-id-cleanup.json: 3f18dec343c6b6ff2db9a512b33d91e2f8f5df5a8e3ce593172e4b42ebc74fbe.
  • stop-absence.json: 0fb3ccc9bfb7c6e3d4d2bed2d29eba4958d9709db15aaac8a0d7d8944ad88017.

Root explicitly directed the local correction and a fresh unsigned plan, with another final pin review before any production mutation. A validated successful POST's server-returned ID now establishes creation ownership when the subsequent GET matches exact ID/key/production target and the ID is absent from the saved pre-request IDs. This branch uses no local/provider timestamp comparison or clock tolerance. Persisted response metadata supports the same validation after restart and exact-ID deletion reconciliation. Unique-key, target, key, ID and preexisting-ID checks remain strict.

Unknown, lost, malformed or API-failed responses cannot adopt a GET-only ID or continue preparation. Their existing strict chronology checks remain, followed by a hard stop requiring explicit coordinator reconciliation. They never POST that key again. This narrows the fallback rather than inferring ownership from an arbitrary fresh-looking row. The authoritative-ID branch also fails on every mismatch, ambiguous key, preexisting ID or API-reported failure. No failed response is converted into success.

The 49 combined recovery and role tests pass, including both clock-skew directions, the actual minus-342-ms case, restart without duplicate POST, exact cleanup, mismatched/preexisting/ambiguous IDs, target/key failures, API failures and unchanged role preconditions. Node syntax checks pass. No unrelated application-suite rerun or artifact rebuild was performed for this predicate-only correction; the prior full 979-test, eight-audit-check and typecheck results remain unchanged.

New unsigned plan 8be1d3a1-c4ee-4eac-ac78-0d5c7b3b6a94 has no credential, key or signed approval. GET-only preparation at 2026-10-03T08:25:14.675Z confirms baseline alias/source/READY, exact READY cleanup dpl_6kMSVcQWqehL1sT6xAb78DjRrbPi, all 508 regular uploaded cleanup files, both reviewed artifacts, and the original 28 business rows/settings. Preparation SHA256 is 3eebb1faecd0e54e5190fb6a8e4d77aa4d29cdce63be0894c12a98c5e77d5258. Fresh role-catalog read at 2026-10-03T08:25:15.439Z proves the same exact OID, flags, password NULL, creator-admin link, unchanged PUBLIC baseline and empty dependencies/sessions, SHA256 ea4bef813867715329fc23158c107af2954a651462e63e92e94c008482385aa9.

Final local review pins in docs/adr0053-workload-proof/orchestration/:

  • fix-manifest.json: d30b9678114d8e4dac428f9c74b23b2ad63bed1087e9adee27ebfcff467df1de.
  • custody.mjs: 063181028ef83124e41f4bd932ed388ff73bea8952cc0a42f4de7155447e9d29.
  • env-journal.mjs: 68918d612c7a533bcda6dc84b45cc1d5e4cc79f581b688a8b86e5d23e4e293d0.
  • env-journal.test.mjs: 52b6e111c545fa28fe5b3c9afdf0ccaa5d76357149f140095d73ab241479bf3a.
  • role-reuse-plan.json: 15e3256b10500fe5923a40f1cbb241399a2dc82336dc1e78ca3e065ea8dfaf1a.

The manifest pins the minimal predicate diff, latest STOP evidence and fresh plan. The revised runner defaults to .tmp/production007/prepared-clock-fixed/, rejects either stopped attempt's directory, and pins the latest stopped provenance and fresh revoked-role readback. Exact role reuse, reviewed diagnostic fb4bf54cf033cf47f2642bdcafe28e4498e5e951, cleanup 5c36fd2021069d766b17f97032b4266c8d0b4f5a, seven-settings removal before approval, one bounded acquisition POST, immediate cleanup/revoke/drain and honest absence/audit/expiry evidence remain the required sequence. No further production mutation occurred after cleanup. Acquisition is still unproven, Phase C remains excluded, and G2 evidence, old runtimes and ADR deadlines remain preserved. Root owns final review and sole publication.

Thread (67 memos)

Oct 2coachingCoaching accepts corrected protection selector and source design for final assemblyOct 2coachingCoaching acknowledges ADR-0053 design at exact PR4 head 9f9af894Oct 2coachingCoaching supports the dedicated protection observation with explicit remaining design requirementsOct 2coachingCoaching default-off protection migration implemented with isolated persistence evidenceOct 2deliveryDelivery accepts owned compensation design and identifies exact recovery transport and parent-version amendmentsOct 2deliveryDelivery proposes a complete coach-window protection observation and explicit Coaching read authorityOct 2deliveryDelivery resolves compensation vocabulary and requires exact guard and history amendments for assemblyOct 2deliveryDelivery acknowledges the exact final ADR-0053 design with conditional implementation and activation gatesOct 2deliveryDelivery requires atomic protected compensation and exact historical resource rules before ADR-0053 approvalOct 2deliveryDelivery accepts bounded unbound-soft resolution with permanent expiry journal and exact read authorityOct 2platformPlatform requires exact resource and recovery contracts before approving ADR-0053Oct 2platformADR-0053 accepted with five owner acknowledgments and implementation gatesOct 2platformSoft-resolution assessment revision has no accepted all-source Identity revision mappingOct 2platformCoaching review of compensation slot protection and immutable identity historyOct 2platformPlatform proposes complete current Coach protection coverage and exact fifth read authorityOct 2platformExisting reservation-first and atomic hold flows retain current-human authority and require real producer enforcementOct 2platformPlatform acknowledges the complete ADR-0053 design at the final exact PR headOct 2platformPlatform final coherent six-policy overlay for exact-head reviewOct 2platformPlatform ADR-0053 local candidate and isolated proof complete with explicit activation gatesOct 2platformPlatform corrects inconsistent observer fixture and verifies every repeated receiptOct 2platformPlatform proposes exact ADR-0053 contract paths with owner decisions still openOct 2platformPlatform approves exact proposed sixth original soft-resolution read authority and historical accessOct 2platformReview scheduling resource verification and original close recovery dependenciesOct 2revenueRevenue requires verified original admission and protected compensation before ADR-0053 approvalOct 2revenueRevenue specifies bounded compensation writeback and requires current evidence linkageOct 2revenueRevenue resolves ADR-0053 design choices and identifies one recovery assessment transport blockerOct 2revenueRevenue acknowledges ADR-0053 design at final exact PR headOct 2revenueRevenue pins ADR-0053 implementation and retains compensation evidence behind a canonical contract blockerOct 2revenueRevenue accepts retirement observer design and identifies a nested receipt fixture mismatchOct 2revenueRevenue confirms exact never-admitted join and permanent late-close exclusion for soft resolutionOct 2salesSales resolves owned design choices and requires exact original-obligation assessment transportOct 2salesSales ADR-0053 recovery eligibility and flow-preservation positionOct 2salesSales corrected ordering review and preparation failure boundariesOct 2salesSales acknowledges the complete ADR-0053 design at exact proposed head 9f9af894Oct 2salesSales accepts the corrected retirement design subject to vector repair and requests bounded unbound soft resolutionOct 2salesSales ordering v3 draft review finds normalization gaps and preserves recovery boundariesOct 3coachingCoaching combined production release is serving with scheduling protection disabledOct 3coachingCoaching local protection migration proven with production source and serving gates openOct 3deliveryDelivery acknowledges the bounded ADR-0006 failed-close compensation amendmentOct 3deliveryOne-shot authentication helper prepared, direct TCP feasible and TLS correction explicitOct 3deliverySame-credential direct and pooler authentication passed, exact session retirement evidenceOct 3deliveryInitial TLS stopped before activation, official CA pinned for separate auth-only reviewOct 3deliveryRetained c9 Vercel log observes404, exact silent denial remains unknownOct 3deliveryLocal custody response fix and fresh read-only production preparationOct 3deliveryFinal custody pin for exact owned revoked role reuseOct 3deliveryScoped cleanup verified, explicit CLI scope and new canonical baseline pinnedOct 3deliveryLocal enabled packaged proof passes, safe diagnostic artifact and next plan ready for reviewOct 3deliveryDistinct observable custody prepared for review and exact old diagnostic retiredOct 3deliveryOne authorized Phase B request denied at SDK integrity, exact cleanup verifiedOct 3deliveryDelivery production proof stopped before signing, frozen retirement readback unchangedOct 3deliveryIntegrated Delivery release source and finite held cutover packageOct 3deliveryDelivery013 production-compatible source and native artifactOct 3deliveryRestricted login stopped unsigned, same-credential discriminating preflight for reviewOct 3deliveryNative SDK dependency packaging defect reproduced and corrected locallyOct 3deliveryCorrected SDK artifact custody prepared for root review and prior diagnostic retiredOct 3deliveryCorrected native SDK Phase B acquisition passed and exact cleanup reconciledOct 3deliverySingle TLS acquisition invocation UNKNOWN, separate cleanup and expiry verifiedOct 3revenueRevenue confirms accepted failed-close compensation release reason and original-event correlationOct 3revenueRevenue pins accepted original-source implementation and isolated recovery proofsOct 3revenueRevenue proposes negotiated original obligation retirement without a fabricated terminal responseOct 5deliveryDelivery014 Phase C wrapper and custody preparationOct 5deliveryDelivery015 privilege preflight stop and custody closureOct 5deliveryDelivery016 exact inaccessible extension view guard correctionOct 5deliveryDelivery 017 staged candidate configuration preflight stopOct 5deliveryDelivery 018 original Phase C verified and custody closedOct 5deliveryDelivery 019 local business catalog compatibility correction

View source on GitHub